Score: 10

"So... amazing..."

submission: Super Mario bros Z ep.8

date: October 10, 2009

With every episode you continue to amaze me. First, of course, your battle sequences are spectacular. The attacks are so inventive and original and work so well in your world. Man, using the tanooki suit to make yourself a weapon... genius! And how each character used the statue differently was so outlandish but at the same time seemed so natural. And the addition of Fire Sonic has me pumped to see what other powerups he could use. And I'm also interested to see how the Chaos Emeralds are eventually used by everyone. Second of all, your use of animation in storytelling has developed well. The closeups make this less of a pixel movie and more like an animated series, which is a good thing. It looks professional and gives it more feeling. Third, your character development has added new tinges to the story that I can't wait to hear more about. You've made shadow into such a deep and troubled character and you have me chomping at the bit to know more about him and his past. Fourth, your writing is spectacular as always. The little things like the one koopa who didn't look right at Luigi and Yoshi with the others helps set the tone of your story which is more light-hearted than you'd think with world domination being a major theme of the story.
Thank you so much for this series. I can't wait for the next installment.

Score: 4

"Disappointing"

submission: One More Brawl Taunts

date: September 20, 2009

Vastly inferior to the first two. The writing wasn't funny, the animation was uninspired, and the whole thing really looked thrown together and forced. The first two videos were fine on their own.

Score: 8

"Oh."

submission: Saturday Morning Watchmen

date: March 17, 2009

Well it was supremely well done but to me it was very anticlimactic. After seeing that hilarious theme song I was all revved up for actually seeing an episode of these Watchmen. I think these faux characters have real potential for a series. There are so many opportunities to do things that are just plain wrong with the characters. Have Nite Owl spout campy Adam West-esque catchphrases! Have Ozymandias provide comic relief as Rorschach uses his ability to talk to animals to save the day from an angry evil electronics corporation that is all up in a tizzy because Jon created the world's perfect TV so he could play Pong on the moon with himself!

...Genius!

Score: 7

"Cute"

submission: If You Were Gay, Roy

date: February 8, 2009

D'awww look at the little chibi Marth and Roy.

Score: 10

"Thanks for the series."

submission: There She Is!! final step

date: December 23, 2008

Well to all good things must come an end. I liked the message that love is not about picking a side in a divisive issue and the answer was not to run from their oppressors.

The music once again was magnificent. One of the biggest strengths of this series has been its harmony with its musical score. The animation and the music always fit perfectly together and make the animation more emotionally powerful. We as observers can connect to the characters and their actions more closely when the music helps to bring out the emotions.

I liked the return to form with a more light-hearted animation. The chase scene was silly enough that it didn't make the issue as serious as it was in ep. 4, which I thought was a mistake. It also ended on a soft note, which I liked. Doki and Nabi are back together and happy. We aren't given any sort of resolution to the harassment they were experiencing and we aren't bothered with any sort of picture into their future relationship. While this does give it somewhat of an anticlimactic feeling, when I thought about it really seeing any more would have made the animation say more than it needed to and more than it should have.

Thanks again for this wonderful series. It has genuinely affected my life. I've taken great pleasure in watching this series develop over the years and you've set the standard for Romeo/Juliet stories. Your work will be remembered for years and years to come. Congratulations.

Score: 6

"Pretty good."

submission: Guitar Geek

date: December 2, 2008

You made this yourself? That's pretty cool. I'd make it so you could modify what keys you use in the options to whatever you want to use. Speedmods would be cool too. Biggest problem is the laughably slow framerate. Game was also too easy. Either make geek mode harder or make an "Impossible" difficulty. I'd like to discuss other things that would improve the game but I'd be breaking promotion rules if I did. Send me a pm if you want to chat.

Score: 2

"What?"

submission: The Sicksons

date: November 20, 2008

If there's a joke here, I'm not getting it. I didn't find anything about this funny. The voices were dumb. There wasn't any real plot to watch. I just don't get what you were trying to accomplish with this. And even if you're not trying to accomplish anything, you should try to be funny, which didn't work for you here.

Score: 8

"Great."

submission: Grand Theft Awesome

date: November 20, 2008

I love Awesome movies. This was well done. Your comedic timing is just as good as Egoraptors. Your "editing" just isn't as crisp. I think if this went through another rewrite it would be spectacular.

Score: 6

"Stale"

submission: The Assumption Song

date: November 20, 2008

Well-written but the idea gets bland after using it like... once.

Score: 9

"Thanks for that"

submission: Chris & Harry

date: November 20, 2008

Made me laugh. You have a good sense of humor and your comedic timing is spot on. I didn't want it to end.